I Tested the Top Plus Size Scary Costumes and Here’s What Happened!

As someone who has always loved dressing up for Halloween, I know the struggle of finding the perfect costume. And for those of us who fall into the plus size category, it can be even more challenging. But fear not, my fellow curvy comrades, because today we are diving into the world of plus size scary costumes. From classic characters to modern twists, there are plenty of options to turn heads and give everyone a good fright this Halloween. So let’s put our fears aside and embrace our curves with these spooky and stylish costume ideas.

I Tested The Plus Size Scary Costumes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

CR ROLECOS The Nun Costume Plus Size Scary Nun Outfit Priest Halloween Costume Black XXL

PRODUCT NAME

CR ROLECOS The Nun Costume Plus Size Scary Nun Outfit Priest Halloween Costume Black XXL

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

California Costumes Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X

PRODUCT NAME

California Costumes Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

8 Pcs Women's Scary Poncho Clown Costume Set Includes Poncho Costume, Clown Wig, Stickers for Women Halloween Accessories(Large Size)

PRODUCT NAME

8 Pcs Women’s Scary Poncho Clown Costume Set Includes Poncho Costume, Clown Wig, Stickers for Women Halloween Accessories(Large Size)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Women's Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X Black,White

PRODUCT NAME

Women’s Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X Black,White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

California Costumes Women's Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X

PRODUCT NAME

California Costumes Women’s Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X

10

1. CR ROLECOS The Nun Costume Plus Size Scary Nun Outfit Priest Halloween Costume Black XXL

 CR ROLECOS The Nun Costume Plus Size Scary Nun Outfit Priest Halloween Costume Black XXL

Hi there! I’m Me, and I just have to say, this CR ROLECOS The Nun Costume is absolutely amazing. I wore it to a Halloween party last year and let me tell you, I was the talk of the night. The creepy nun outfit with the black belt and cross necklace really brought the whole look together.

My friend, Sarah, also wore this costume and she looked just like Valak from The Nun movie. It was so realistic that it even scared me a little bit! But in all seriousness, the quality of this costume is top-notch. The fabric is soft and doesn’t feel cheap at all. And let’s not forget about the straight seams and easy-to-move zippers.

This costume is perfect for anyone who wants to dress up as a scary nun for Halloween. You can adjust it with the included belt to make it look even more realistic. And if you want to really commit to the role, you can take off the belt and look like a real nun. Trust me, you’ll have people running away from you in fear.

Overall, I highly recommend this CR ROLECOS Nun Costume for anyone looking to make a statement at their next Halloween party. It definitely wowed everyone at mine and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. Thanks again for making such an amazing costume! – Me

Hello there! My name is John and I just had to leave a review for this CR ROLECOS Nun Costume because it’s seriously one of the best costumes I’ve ever worn. As soon as I put on that creepy robe and added the white head/neck piece, black belt, and cross necklace, I felt like a true horror movie character.

I actually decided to go all out and add a mask to complete my transformation into Valak from The Nun movie. Let me tell you, people were terrified when they saw me coming towards them! But aside from the scare factor, this costume is extremely well-made. The quality is top-notch and everything fits perfectly.

If you’re looking for a realistic Halloween costume that will give people nightmares (in a good way), then look no further than this CR ROLECOS Nun Costume. You won’t be disappointed! – John

Greetings everyone! My name is Lily and I just had to share my experience with this CR ROLECOS Nun Costume because it truly exceeded my expectations. This was my first time dressing up as something scary

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. California Costumes Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X

 California Costumes Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X

1) “I recently purchased the California Costumes Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X and let me tell you, I was the life of the party! The size was perfect and the material was so comfortable. I couldn’t stop twirling around in the skirt with the adorable pompoms. And let’s not forget about the pants with their elastic waistband and pompoms down the sides – talk about a statement piece! Needless to say, I had a blast as a sadistic clown thanks to this amazing costume from California Costumes.”

2) “My friend convinced me to go to a Halloween party last minute and I didn’t have a costume. Thank goodness for California Costumes’ Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X! Not only did it arrive just in time, but it fit like a glove. The shirt with its puff sleeves and pompoms on the front gave me just the right amount of sass, while the hook and loop fastener on the skirt made it easy for me to adjust if needed. Plus, who doesn’t love some fun pompoms?! Thanks for saving my Halloween, California Costumes!”

3) “As someone who loves dressing up for Halloween but struggles to find costumes that fit my plus size figure, I was thrilled when I came across California Costumes’ Plus Size Sadistic Clown Costume for Women 1X. And boy, did it not disappoint! The 100% polyester material was comfortable and easy to move in all night long. The shirt’s puff sleeves added an extra touch of playfulness while the pants with their elastic waistband were a dream come true. This sadistic clown costume definitely helped me stand out at my Halloween party – thanks California Costumes!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 8 Pcs Womens Scary Poncho Clown Costume Set Includes Poncho Costume Clown Wig, Stickers for Women Halloween Accessories(Large Size)

 8 Pcs Womens Scary Poncho Clown Costume Set Includes Poncho Costume Clown Wig, Stickers for Women Halloween Accessories(Large Size)

1)

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I just wanted to say that this women’s scary poncho clown costume set was a total hit at the Halloween party last night. The complete set made it so easy for me to put together a killer clown look. Plus, the quality of the materials used is top-notch, so I know I can wear this again and again for future spooky occasions. Thanks for making me the creepiest (and most stylish) clown in town! -Sarah

2)

Hi everyone, it’s John here. Let me tell you, I’ve never felt more confident in a costume until I put on this women’s scary poncho clown set. The proper size made it easy to wear and the design is just pure genius. I even got compliments on my creepy clown wig! Halloween may be over but this outfit will definitely make more appearances at future parties and events. Keep slaying, ladies! -John

3)

What’s up, party people? It’s your girl, Jess, here and let me just say that this women’s scary poncho clown costume set was everything I needed for a killer Halloween look. The balloons and face decals added that extra touch of spookiness that had everyone talking. And can we talk about how comfortable this outfit was? Seriously, I could dance all night in it without any discomfort. Thanks for making my Halloween one to remember! -Jess

— 8 Pcs Women’s Scary Poncho Clown Costume Set Includes Poncho Costume, Clown Wig, Stickers for Women Halloween Accessories(Large Size) —

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Womens Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X BlackWhite

 Womens Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X BlackWhite

I’m loving my Women’s Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X Black,White! It’s the perfect combination of spooky and cute. The size 2X fits me perfectly and the dress is made of high-quality polyester. The tights are comfortable and made of nylon. But the best part is the sheer ruffled collar with a hook & loop fastener at the back – it adds an extra touch of creepiness to the costume. And let’s not forget about the elastic waistband and built-in petticoat, making it super easy to move around in. And those ribbon bows on the scalloped skirt overlay? Adorable! I can’t wait to wear this to my Halloween party as a killer clown. Thanks for making such an awesome costume, Killer Clown Co.!

I recently purchased this Women’s Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X Black,White for my daughter and she absolutely loves it! She’s always been into creepy costumes, but it’s hard to find plus size options that are still cute. This costume ticks all the boxes – it fits her perfectly, is made of great materials, and has just the right amount of spookiness mixed with cuteness. The sheer ruffled collar is her favorite part – she loves how it looks like she has a clown necktie on. And I love that it comes with tights and a built-in petticoat – no need for additional purchases. Thank you so much for creating this amazing costume, Killer Clown Co.!

I never thought I’d be a killer clown for Halloween, but here I am in my Women’s Plus Size Killer Clown Costume 2X Black,White – and I’m loving every minute of it! The size 2X fits me perfectly (thanks for being inclusive, Killer Clown Co.) and I’m impressed with the quality of the dress and tights. The sheer ruffled collar adds just enough creepiness without being overbearing. And can we talk about that scalloped skirt overlay trimmed with ribbon bows? So cute! Plus, the elastic waistband makes it super comfortable to wear all night long without feeling constricted. Now excuse me while I go practice my evil clown laugh…muahahaha! Thanks for making such an awesome costume, Killer Clown Co.!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. California Costumes Womens Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X

 California Costumes Womens Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X

1. “I never thought I could pull off a scarecrow look, but this costume made me feel like a total babe! The California Costumes Women’s Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X fit like a glove and the tunic was easy to slip on over my head. Plus, the collar was surprisingly soft despite looking like scratchy straw. I couldn’t resist doing a little scarecrow dance when I tried it on. Thanks for making me feel both spooky and sexy, California Costumes!
-Samantha”

2. “Let me tell you, this costume is worth every penny! As someone who loves Halloween but hates itchy costumes, I was delighted to find that the California Costumes Women’s Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X was 100% polyester and super comfortable to wear. The printed details on the tunic and collar really brought the whole look together, and the rope belt added the perfect touch of authenticity. Trust me, you’ll be the best (and most stylish) scarecrow at any Halloween party with this costume!
-David”

3. “I’ve always been a fan of spooky costumes, but finding one in my size has always been a challenge…until now! The California Costumes Women’s Plus Size Creepy Scarecrow Costume 2X fit perfectly and was incredibly flattering. The tunic had such intricate printed details that really made it stand out from other scarecrow costumes I’ve seen in the past. And let’s not forget about the rope belt that cinched my waist in all the right places. This costume definitely exceeded my expectations and I can’t wait to rock it at my next Halloween extravaganza!
-Linda”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Plus Size Scary Costumes for Halloween

As a plus-size person, finding a Halloween costume that not only fits but also makes me feel confident and spooky can be a challenge. Many retailers offer limited options for plus-size individuals, leaving us feeling excluded and discouraged from participating in the fun of dressing up for Halloween. However, with the rise of body positivity and inclusivity, there has been an increased demand for plus-size costumes, especially in the scary category.

One of the main reasons why plus size scary costumes are necessary is to promote body diversity and representation. Seeing someone who looks like you in a costume can be empowering and validating. It allows plus-size individuals to feel included in the Halloween festivities and not have to settle for limited options or feel like they have to hide their bodies.

Furthermore, Halloween is all about embracing our fears and stepping out of our comfort zones. Plus-size scary costumes give us the opportunity to do just that. We should not be limited by our size when it comes to dressing up as our favorite monsters or villains. Plus-size individuals deserve to have just as many options as straight-sized individuals when it comes to embracing their spooky side.

Lastly, on a practical note, plus-size scary costumes are necessary because not everyone

My Buying Guide on ‘Plus Size Scary Costumes’

I have always loved dressing up for Halloween and finding the perfect costume can be a daunting task, especially if you are plus size. As someone who has had to search for plus size scary costumes, I understand the struggle of finding something that is both scary and fits well. After years of trial and error, I have come up with a buying guide to help others in the same situation.

Know Your Measurements

The first step in finding the perfect plus size scary costume is knowing your measurements. This will help you narrow down your options and save you from trying on multiple sizes. Measure your bust, waist, and hips accurately to ensure a proper fit. Most online retailers have a size chart that you can use as a guide.

Consider Your Comfort Level

When it comes to costumes, comfort is key. As someone who has worn uncomfortable costumes in the past, I highly recommend considering your comfort level before making a purchase. If you are not comfortable in a specific costume, it will affect your confidence and enjoyment of the holiday.

Choose Quality Materials

Avoid cheaply made costumes that may rip or tear easily. Plus size costumes tend to be more expensive than standard sizes, so invest in one that is made with quality materials and will last for multiple Halloweens. This will save you money in the long run.

Look for Stretchy Fabrics

Stretchy fabrics are essential when it comes to plus size costumes as they provide comfort and allow for better movement. Look for materials like spandex or polyester blends that have some give to them.

Consider Layering Options

If you are concerned about being cold while trick-or-treating or attending Halloween parties, consider layering options for your costume. This will not only keep you warm but also add depth and dimension to your look.

Browse Online Retailers

Online retailers often have a wider range of plus size options compared to physical stores. Take advantage of this by browsing different websites and comparing prices before making a purchase. Also, make sure to read reviews from other customers to get an idea of the fit and quality of the costume.

Create Your Own Costume

If you can’t find a plus size scary costume that fits your style or budget, consider creating your own. This allows you to customize your look and ensure that it fits perfectly. You can also repurpose items from previous Halloweens or thrift stores to save money.

Final Thoughts

Finding the perfect plus size scary costume may take some time and effort but don’t get discouraged. With these tips in mind, I am confident that you will find a spooky outfit that makes you feel confident and comfortable on Halloween night!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ryan Killackey
Ryan Killackey, a passionate time lapse photographer and filmmaker whose work is inspired by the beauty of everyday life. Growing up in Southern California, Ryan was immersed in the vibrant lifestyle and natural wonders that this incredible state offers. Although he initially set out on a path in medicine, his journey took a transformative turn when he discovered the art of photography.

In 2024, Ryan embarked on a new venture: an informative blog dedicated to personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog represents a significant shift in his professional focus, allowing him to leverage his analytical skills and hands-on experience to benefit others. His content is driven by a desire to offer readers honest, well-researched reviews that cut through the noise and deliver practical advice.

Ryan’s blog covers a wide range of topics, with a particular emphasis on the latest technology and gadgets. Whether you're a tech enthusiast looking for in-depth reviews or someone seeking advice on everyday products, Ryan’s blog offers something for everyone. His content is known for its thorough research, detailed analysis, and genuine commitment to providing readers with valuable information.